Analytics cookies only (Google Analytics, PostHog). No ad networks, no cross-site tracking. See our privacy policy.
upstream: github.com/0xERR0R/blocky (opens in new tab) · github.com/pi-hole/pi-hole (opens in new tab)
Pick Blocky
If you prefer configuration as a YAML file you can keep in git, want per-group lists and upstreams and Prometheus metrics, and do not need a dashboard.
Pick Pi-hole
If you want a web interface to manage lists and groups and the lower idle RAM we measured (~10 MB against ~18 MB).
Blocky and Pi-hole both block ads by answering DNS: a request for a listed domain gets no useful answer, so the connection never starts. The interface is where they split. Pi-hole gives you a web dashboard; Blocky is configured from a YAML file and has no web UI at all, and in return it is a single Go binary that suits people who already manage services as config files. If you are comparing Pi-hole with another dashboard-based option, Pi-hole vs AdGuard Home covers it.
Pi-hole's docs call it "a DNS sinkhole that protects your devices from
unwanted content, without installing any client-side software", with "a
beautiful responsive Web Interface dashboard to view and control your
Pi-hole" and optional DHCP. It is built around a C resolver, pihole-FTL.
Blocky's README lists the features that matter here: "Simple configuration - single or multiple configuration files in YAML format", "Definition of allow/denylists per client group (Kids, Smart home devices, etc.)", and "Various REST API endpoints" plus a CLI tool. It does not mention a web UI, and our catalog entry describes it as having none.
So the choice is partly about how you want to operate it: click through a dashboard, or edit a file and restart.
Pi-hole's docs have sections on group management, regex blocking and editing allow and deny lists, alongside the dashboard.
In Blocky you declare everything in config.yml: upstream resolvers, deny lists
by group, and which client groups use which list. Our install blocks with the
StevenBlack hosts list and gives a default group to the ads list. The same
group mechanism supports a stricter list for some clients, and per the README,
"Upstream resolvers can be defined per client group". The REST API reports
blocking status (our health check reads /api/blocking/status).
Blocky's feature list includes "Customizable caching of DNS answers for queries", "Prefetching and caching of often used queries", "Custom DNS resolution for certain domain names" and "Conditional forwarding to external DNS server". Its README lists DNS over HTTPS, TLS and QUIC among the supported protocols, and our snippet uses a mix of plain, DoT and DoH upstreams.
Observability is where Blocky leans toward operators: "Prometheus metrics", "Prepared Grafana dashboards (Prometheus and database)", and "Logging of DNS queries per day / per client in CSV format", with database logging options. For upstream DNS, Pi-hole's docs list guides for companion tools such as unbound, cloudflared and dnscrypt-proxy.
Blocky is listed as Apache-2.0 and Pi-hole as EUPL-1.2. Either is fine for a private install.
We list a minimum of 256 MB of RAM for Blocky, our own estimate, and 512 MB for Pi-hole, the figure in Pi-hole's prerequisites. In our install check (GCP e2-standard-2, Ubuntu 26.04), idle at first boot with the default install snippet and no real client traffic, Blocky used ~18 MB of RAM and ~48 MB of disk (November 2026), and Pi-hole used ~10 MB of RAM and ~173 MB of disk (September 2026). Those are idle numbers, not a busy network with large lists loaded.
Both are 2 out of 5. Our Blocky snippet is a short config.yml plus a
one-service compose file, with DNS on port 5353 and the REST API on 4000. Pi-hole
is one compose file with port 53, the dashboard at /admin, and a note on freeing
port 53 from systemd-resolved on Ubuntu.
Choose Blocky if you prefer configuration as a YAML file you can keep in git, want per-group lists and upstreams, Prometheus metrics, and the smallest disk footprint we measured, and do not need a dashboard.
Choose Pi-hole if you want a web interface to manage lists and read the query log, and the lower idle RAM we measured.
Both installs are verified on Ubuntu 26.04; the files are on the Blocky and Pi-hole pages. Do not leave an open resolver on a public IP: restrict who can query it (a VPN or firewall rules).
Blocky lists a lower minimum: 256 MB vs 512 MB for Pi-hole.
No. Blocky is Apache-2.0, Pi-hole is EUPL-1.2.
Blocky if you like a single YAML config, per-client-group lists and upstreams, and Prometheus metrics, and can live without a dashboard. Pi-hole if you want a web interface for lists and groups. In our first-boot check (idle, not under load) Pi-hole used ~10 MB of RAM and Blocky ~18 MB.
Blocky's README does not mention one; it lists REST API endpoints and a CLI tool, and our catalog entry describes it as having no web UI. You configure it in YAML and can read its status through the API.
Yes. Its README lists "Definition of allow/denylists per client group (Kids, Smart home devices, etc.)" and says upstream resolvers can also be defined per client group.
Blocky in our check: ~48 MB against ~173 MB for Pi-hole at first boot with the default install snippets.
Paid link — we earn a commission if you shop through it.
A full authoritative and recursive DNS server that also blocks ads, or the single-purpose ad-blocking sinkhole with a dashboard.
The community classic vs. the single-binary upstart.
A whiteboard-and-docs workspace on a plain Compose file vs. native apps on a commercial server.