Analytics cookies only (Google Analytics, PostHog). No ad networks, no cross-site tracking. See our privacy policy.
upstream: github.com/Infisical/infisical (opens in new tab) · github.com/hashicorp/vault (opens in new tab)
Pick Infisical
If developers are the main users and you want a web editor with environments, a CLI that injects secrets into runs and CI, certificates in the same app, and can spare about 995 MB of idle RAM and check its paid list for versioning, rotation or dynamic secrets.
Pick Vault
If machines are the main users, you want leased, auto-revoked credentials, many auth methods and encryption as a service from a single small container, and the Business Source terms suit you.
Infisical and HashiCorp Vault both keep application secrets such as database
passwords, API keys and certificates out of .env files and git, but they start
from opposite ends. Infisical is a dashboard for developers: projects,
environments, a CLI and a web editor, running on PostgreSQL and Redis. Vault is
an API-first secrets engine for machines: policies, leases, credentials it
generates on demand, and a server that starts sealed. They also differ on
licensing, in different ways: Vault's source is under the Business Source
License, while Infisical is MIT at its core with paid enterprise modules. If
you want Vault's model under an open licence, read
OpenBao vs Vault and
Infisical vs OpenBao.
Infisical calls itself "the open source security infrastructure platform that teams use for secrets, certificates" and more. Its README lists secrets management ("across every environment"), secret rotation, dynamic secrets, secret scanning, PKI for X.509 certificates and a KMS for keys. You organise secrets by project and environment and edit them in the web UI.
Vault's README describes "Secure Secret Storage", "Dynamic Secrets" generated on demand "for some systems, such as AWS or SQL databases", "Data Encryption" ("Vault can encrypt and decrypt data without storing it"), "Leasing and Renewal" and "Revocation". Clients authenticate through an auth method (AppRole, Kubernetes, JWT/OIDC, LDAP, GitHub and others) and receive policies. Its database engine "generates database credentials dynamically based on configured roles", for PostgreSQL, MySQL/MariaDB, MongoDB, MSSQL and Cassandra among others.
In practice: if the question is "where does the team edit DATABASE_URL for
staging and production", Infisical answers it directly. If the question is
"how does this service get a database login that expires in an hour", that is
what Vault was built for.
Vault is under the Business Source License 1.1 for "Vault Version 1.15.0 or later". The Additional Use Grant allows production use as long as you do not offer it to third parties "on a hosted or embedded basis in order to compete" with IBM's paid versions, and the licence converts to MPL 2.0 four years after each version is published. Vault Enterprise is a separate paid edition, and its docs place replication, performance standby nodes, namespaces, HSM support, control groups and more under it.
Infisical says its repo is "available under the MIT expat license", with the
ee directories excluded; they "contain premium enterprise features requiring
an Infisical license". Its pricing page puts secret versioning and
point-in-time recovery, SAML SSO, custom roles, approval workflows and secret
rotation in paid plans, and the dynamic-secrets docs say they need a paid
licence, which self-hosters buy by contacting sales. So the headline feature the two
share, short-lived credentials, is free in Vault's core and paid in Infisical.
Conversely, Infisical's developer dashboard is free; Vault's UI is too, but
policy-writing is the main work.
Vault starts sealed. Its docs say "the default Vault configuration uses an
algorithm known as Shamir's Secret Sharing", splitting the key and requiring "a
certain threshold of shares" to rebuild it. After every restart someone must
unseal, unless you configure auto unseal ("aids in reducing the operational
complexity of keeping the unseal key secure"). Our snippet runs in server mode
with file storage and says to run operator init, save the keys and root token
offline, and unseal three times. Vault's docs say the filesystem backend "does
not support high availability", which is fine for one server and the wrong
backend for a cluster.
Infisical does not seal. Secrets are encrypted in PostgreSQL with the
ENCRYPTION_KEY from .env. Its Docker guide says "Without this key, you cannot
decrypt secrets even if you restore the database", and that "The first user to
sign up becomes the instance administrator", so create that account before
exposing the URL. It also warns: "Never expose PostgreSQL (5432) or Redis
(6379) ports to the public internet."
Infisical needs three or four services: the app, PostgreSQL and Redis, plus a reverse proxy in our snippet for HTTPS. Its self-hosting docs list PostgreSQL and Redis as required dependencies. Vault is a single Go container.
On a GCP e2-standard-2 (Ubuntu 26.04), idle at first boot with an empty install, Infisical used ~995 MB of RAM and ~3.4 GB of disk (October 2026), while Vault used ~23 MB of RAM and ~731 MB of disk (November 2026). These are first-boot readings with no secrets and no clients, not a load test. Our minimums are estimates: 4 GB for Infisical and 512 MB for Vault.
We rate Infisical 2 out of 5 and Vault 3 out of 5. Infisical has more containers to run. Vault's single container is simple to start, but you have to initialise, unseal, write policies and add TLS before it is useful.
Choose Infisical if developers are the main users, if you want a web editor with environments, a CLI that injects secrets into local runs and CI, and certificate management in the same app, and if you can spend the RAM (~995 MB idle) and check the paid list for versioning, rotation or dynamic secrets first.
Choose Vault if machines are the main users, if you want leased, auto-revoked credentials from the free core, many auth methods and encryption as a service from a very small process, and if the Business Source terms suit you. If they do not, OpenBao is the MPL-2.0 fork.
Both installs are verified on Ubuntu 26.04; the snippets are on the
Infisical and Vault pages. Give
Infisical a plan with 4 GB of RAM and a domain for HTTPS; Vault fits a much
smaller one. Back up Infisical's ENCRYPTION_KEY separately from the pg_data
volume, and Vault's data volume plus its unseal keys, stored offline.
HashiCorp Vault lists a lower minimum: 512 MB vs 4096 MB for Infisical.
No. Infisical is MIT core with proprietary enterprise modules, HashiCorp Vault is BSL-1.1.
Infisical when the main users are developers who want a dashboard, environments and a CLI, and you can give it PostgreSQL, Redis and about 995 MB of idle RAM. Vault when machines authenticate on their own and you want leased, short-lived credentials from a ~23 MB container. Both figures are first-boot idle readings from our test box.
No. Infisical does not seal; secrets are encrypted in PostgreSQL with the ENCRYPTION_KEY from .env, and its Docker guide says "Without this key, you cannot decrypt secrets even if you restore the database". Vault starts sealed after every restart unless you configure auto unseal.
In Vault, the database and cloud secrets engines are part of the core build; BSL licensing and a separate Enterprise edition apply. In Infisical, the docs put dynamic secrets in a paid plan, and self-hosters buy a licence by contacting sales.
Vault 1.15.0 and later is under the Business Source License 1.1, which is source-available rather than OSI open source. Production use is allowed except hosted or embedded offerings that compete with IBM's paid versions, and each version converts to MPL 2.0 four years after publication. OpenBao is the MPL-2.0 fork.
Paid link — we earn a commission if you shop through it.
The MPL-2.0 community fork under the Linux Foundation, or HashiCorp's original now under the Business Source License.
The developer secrets dashboard vs. the open-source Vault fork.
A whiteboard-and-docs workspace on a plain Compose file vs. native apps on a commercial server.