Analytics cookies only (Google Analytics, PostHog). No ad networks, no cross-site tracking. See our privacy policy.
upstream: github.com/navidrome/navidrome (opens in new tab) · github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin (opens in new tab)
Pick Navidrome
If your library is music only: it idled at ~16 MB here, works with any Subsonic, Madsonic or Airsonic client, and keeps per-user play counts, playlists and scrobbling.
Pick Jellyfin
If music is one library among movies, shows, live TV, books and photos and you want one server, one login and first-party apps for all of it, on a ~170 MB idle footprint.
Navidrome and Jellyfin both sit in the Media server category and both will stream a music folder to your phone, but they are different shapes of tool. Navidrome calls itself "an open source web-based music collection server and streamer": music is the whole product. Jellyfin is "a Free Software Media System that puts you in control of managing and streaming your media", and music is one of the media types it lists, beside movies, shows, live TV, books and photos. If your library is only music, the question is how much server you want around it. If you already run Jellyfin for video, the question is whether music deserves its own box.
Navidrome does one thing. Its overview promises that it "Handles very large music collections", "Streams virtually any audio format available" and has "Very low resource usage. Runs well even on simple Raspberry Pi Zero and old hardware setups". Nothing on that page mentions video, and that is the point: no libraries to configure for other media, no second set of settings.
Jellyfin is the general server. Its home page lists "Movies", "Shows", "Music", "Live TV & DVR", "Books" and "Photos", and says that "With a large array of official and third-party clients, Jellyfin is available on most popular platforms". Music here is a library type like any other, served by the same server, users and clients as your films. That is an advantage if one household wants one login and one app for everything, and overhead if you only wanted the playlists.
Both read the metadata already in your files. Navidrome "Reads and uses all your beautifully curated metadata" and "Automatically monitors your library for changes, importing new files and reloading new metadata", so a new album dropped into the folder appears without a manual scan.
Jellyfin's music docs are more prescriptive about layout: "Albums are organized
in folders, with one folder containing one and only one album." Names matter less
than the tags ("Filenames generally do not matter since the info will be
scraped from the embedded metadata of the tracks"), though without tags
"Jellyfin uses the file names as track titles". Multi-disc albums are recognised
from the disc number and total discs tags, and the docs list a few traps:
audio-only .mp4, .mkv and .webm files "aren't recognized as music" until
renamed to .m4a or .mka, and ID3v1 tags truncate fields to 30 bytes. Lyrics
files sit beside the audio with a matching name, and both synchronised and
unsynchronised formats are supported.
If your collection is already tagged and tidy, both are painless. If it is a decade of mixed folders, expect to spend more time with Jellyfin's rules.
This is the clearest practical difference. Navidrome is "Compatible with all Subsonic/Madsonic/Airsonic clients", so the choice of player app is yours and is not tied to the server. Per-user state lives on the server: "Multi-user, each user has their own play counts, playlists, favorites, etc..". It also lists "Smart/dynamic playlists (similar to iTunes)", noted in the docs as beta, and "Scrobbling to Last.fm, ListenBrainz and Maloja (via custom ListenBrainz URL)".
Jellyfin ships its own clients: Web, Desktop, Android, Apple, Amazon, Roku and Kodi appear on its home page, and a Mopidy extension is documented. They are one app family for video and music, which is simplest if you want a single app everywhere. Jellyfin has no built-in Subsonic API (a third-party plugin, Subfin, adds an "OpenSubsonic-compatible REST API"); the usual route is a music app built for Jellyfin's own API, such as Finamp, "a free Jellyfin music player for Android, iOS and Desktop".
Navidrome's overview says "Transcoding on the fly. Can be set per user/player. Opus encoding is supported", which is the audio case: shrink a lossless file for a mobile connection.
Jellyfin's transcoder is built for video as well. Its documentation says the server "can offload on the fly video transcoding" and lists six validated methods: Intel Quick Sync, NVIDIA NVDEC/NVENC, AMD AMF, VA-API on Linux, Apple Video Toolbox on macOS and Rockchip RKMPP on Linux; the transcoder is "a modified version of FFmpeg". For a music-only server that machinery mostly sits unused; for a mixed library it is the reason Jellyfin exists. For how it compares with a commercial server, see Plex vs Jellyfin.
Navidrome is GPL-3.0 and Jellyfin GPL-2.0 per our catalogue. Jellyfin says it is "Free Software, licensed under the GNU GPL", that "There are no costs, hidden or otherwise, to use Jellyfin", and that it "has no tracking, phone-home, or central servers collecting your data". Navidrome's overview lists no paid tier. Neither of our install snippets needs an account with the project.
Navidrome publishes no RAM minimum, so our 256 MB floor is an estimate. Jellyfin's hardware guide is far more generous than our 1 GB floor: "at least 8GB is recommended for the average deployment", and "For a Linux server running without a GUI, 4GB may be enough". That sizing covers video transcoding; a music-only library needs much less. What we have is measurement. On our GCP e2-standard-2 test box (Ubuntu 26.04), idle at first boot with the default install snippet, Navidrome used ~16 MB of RAM and ~333 MB of disk (September 2026), and Jellyfin ~170 MB of RAM and ~2.4 GB of disk (September 2026). That is idle, not production load: scanning a large collection or transcoding will use more on either.
Navidrome's snippet is one docker run on port 4533 with /data for "its DB and
cache" and the music folder at /music (the docs' compose example mounts it
read-only with :ro); it runs as your own user, so the data folder must be writable by that UID. Jellyfin's is a
compose file with /config and a media mount on port 8096. We rate Navidrome
2 out of 5 and Jellyfin 3 out of 5. Both are plain HTTP, so put a reverse
proxy with TLS in front before exposing either.
Choose Navidrome if your library is music only, you want the smallest server that does it (it idled at ~16 MB here), and you like choosing your own Subsonic client with per-user play counts, playlists and scrobbling.
Choose Jellyfin if music is one library among several, you want one server, one login and one first-party app family for films, shows and albums, and you are happy to follow its folder-per-album conventions on a ~170 MB idle server.
You can also run both against the same music folder, since Navidrome only needs read access to it, but that doubles the servers to maintain.
Either fits the smallest plan most providers sell for a personal library. The
real costs are storage for the music and, for Jellyfin, CPU if you transcode
video. Keep the media on a separate volume you back up on its own, and keep
Navidrome's /data or Jellyfin's /config in your backups too, since that is
where playlists, play counts and users live. Both installs are on the
Navidrome and Jellyfin pages.
No. Navidrome is GPL-3.0, Jellyfin is GPL-2.0.
Navidrome if music is all you need: it calls itself a music collection server and streamer, idled at ~16 MB of RAM in our check, and works with any Subsonic, Madsonic or Airsonic client. Jellyfin if the same server should also hold movies, shows, live TV, books and photos, with one login and its own apps. Jellyfin idled at ~170 MB in the same check.
Not out of the box: Jellyfin has no built-in Subsonic API, and a third-party plugin (Subfin) is the only way to add one. The usual route is a player built for Jellyfin, such as Finamp, a free Jellyfin music player for Android, iOS and desktop. Navidrome states it is compatible with all Subsonic, Madsonic and Airsonic clients, so that is the route to a free choice of Subsonic player.
Navidrome reads the tags already in your files and monitors the library for changes. Jellyfin's docs ask for one album per folder, identify multi-disc albums from the disc number and total discs tags, and note that audio-only mp4, mkv and webm files are not recognised as music until renamed to m4a or mka.
Navidrome publishes no RAM minimum, so our 256 MB floor is an estimate. Jellyfin's hardware guide recommends at least 8 GB for the average deployment and says 4 GB may be enough on a headless Linux server, sizing that covers video transcoding; our 1 GB floor is for a light library. On our GCP e2-standard-2 box with Ubuntu 26.04, idle at first boot with the default install, Navidrome used ~16 MB of RAM and ~333 MB of disk and Jellyfin ~170 MB and ~2.4 GB. Scanning a large library or transcoding will use more.
Paid link — we earn a commission if you shop through it.
Polished and easy, or fully free and open?
Same family tree — one pays for the GPU, one doesn't.
A whiteboard-and-docs workspace on a plain Compose file vs. native apps on a commercial server.