Analytics cookies only (Google Analytics, PostHog). No ad networks, no cross-site tracking. See our privacy policy.
upstream: github.com/getarcaneapp/arcane (opens in new tab) · github.com/portainer/portainer (opens in new tab)
Pick Arcane
If you run Docker or Podman hosts and want Git-synced Compose projects, OIDC, passkeys and image scanning with no edition split.
Pick Portainer CE
If you manage Kubernetes, want the lower footprint we measured (~19 MB against ~123 MB idle RAM), or may move to Business Edition for RBAC, audit and support.
Arcane and Portainer both put a web interface over Docker. Portainer is the established one, covering Docker, Swarm, Podman and Kubernetes, with a Community Edition and a paid Business Edition. Arcane is a newer interface for Docker and Podman hosts with a single permissive licence and Compose projects, Git sync and vulnerability scanning in the box. For another Portainer comparison see Komodo vs Portainer.
Arcane's site describes "Clean, intuitive design that makes Docker management a breeze", with container, image, network and volume management, "Visual graphs for CPU, memory, and network usage" and "Scan images for known vulnerabilities right from the dashboard". Its docs list Projects with Git Sync and GitOps lifecycle hooks, "OIDC Single Sign-On", passkeys and roles, and "Manage other Docker hosts with agents".
Portainer CE's README calls it "a free, lightweight container management UI for Docker, Swarm, Podman, Kubernetes, and ACI environments".
Arcane's site states it is "Always free. Forever. Never changing." and mentions no paid tier. SSO, Git sync and agents are in its docs without an edition split.
Portainer splits features by edition. Its README says Business Edition adds "RBAC, GitOps, edge management, audit, SSO, and more", and its features page lists GitOps automatic updates and webhooks under Business Edition, which is free for 3 nodes. Portainer's CE vs BE post says CE "supports LDAP and OAuth in a more limited form without the AD support or provider templates", and its table gives CE "Basic Git deployment". The README also says CE is for "homelabs, learning environments, personal projects, and other non-production deployments", with no support or SLA.
Both handle Docker, Swarm and Podman. Arcane's docs say "Run Arcane on Podman and manage pods, Quadlets, Kubernetes YAML, and secrets." Kubernetes is the clearer difference: Portainer's README lists Kubernetes environments, while the only Kubernetes entry in Arcane's docs is that YAML feature under Podman.
Arcane is BSD-3-Clause and Portainer CE is zlib, both permissive. The difference is that Portainer's gated features live in a separate paid edition.
We list 256 MB minimum RAM for both, our own estimate; we found no documented figure upstream. In our install check (GCP e2-standard-2, Ubuntu 26.04), idle at first boot with the default install snippet and no real workload, Portainer used ~19 MB of RAM and ~192 MB of disk (October 2026), and Arcane used ~123 MB of RAM and ~229 MB of disk (November 2026). The readings are two weeks apart. Disk is docker system df for the install.
Portainer is 1 out of 5: one docker run, HTTPS on 9443 with a self-signed certificate and a setup token to use within 5 minutes. Arcane is 2 out of 5: a compose file with a generated ENCRYPTION_KEY, a data volume, a projects directory and the UI on port 3552, with SQLite inside the container. Its default login is arcane / arcane-admin and the UI asks you to change it.
Choose Arcane if you run Docker or Podman hosts, want Git-synced Compose projects, OIDC or passkeys and image scanning without an edition split, and can live with a newer project.
Choose Portainer if you manage Kubernetes, want the lowest idle RAM we measured, or may later want the Business Edition's RBAC, audit and support.
Both installs are verified on Ubuntu 26.04; the files are on the Arcane and Portainer CE pages. Both mount the Docker socket, so keep the admin page off the open internet, and change Arcane's default password at first login.
No. Arcane is BSD-3-Clause, Portainer CE is Zlib.
Arcane for Docker or Podman hosts with Git-synced projects, OIDC and image scanning in a single free edition (~123 MB idle in our check). Portainer CE for Kubernetes and the lowest idle RAM (~19 MB).
Its README lists RBAC, GitOps, edge management, audit and SSO as Business Edition additions. Portainer's CE vs BE post says CE keeps LDAP and OAuth in a more limited form, without Active Directory or provider templates. Business Edition is free for 3 nodes.
Its site says Arcane is always free and mentions no paid tier.
Our install uses arcane / arcane-admin and the UI asks you to change the password at first sign-in.
Paid link — we earn a commission if you shop through it.
The multi-server build-and-deploy tool vs. the container UI with a paid Business Edition.
A small compose-stack editor for a host or two, or a multi-server platform with builds, procedures and an audit trail.
A compose-stack editor that leaves your files on disk, or a broad container UI for Docker, Swarm, Podman and Kubernetes.